Well, here we go. It's just after midnight as I'm writing this, and it looks like the Senate is going to vote today on a bill that will give
$300 billion to troubled home owners. I know we all want to be compassionate and help those in need. I also know it's a touchy subject when you're talking about people's homes, but is anyone else starting to get bothered by all these government bailouts of bad decisions? Isn't the ability to make decisions and live with consequences, good or bad, part of what freedom and liberty are all about? A little quick mental math here. There are approximately 300 million citizens living in the United States. To me, that comes out to a cost of $1000 for every man, woman, and child living in the US to fund this bill. Or we'll just tack it onto the
debt. I know this may sound extraordinarily harsh, but why should we have to pay that?
Four years ago, I signed an agreement with a bank when I bought my house which has certain terms. If I fail to abide by those terms, the bank makes it very clear that they will come repossess the house. Because I value a roof over my head, I've decided to only take on a house payment that I can afford.
Now, I wasn't at the signing for all these homes and homeowners which are now in trouble. I didn't have a chance to look over the agreements to make sure the owner would be able to pay it, or the lender wasn't making a pie-in-the-sky offer too good to be true. I'm failing to comprehend why my family should be on the hook for bad decisions, both by the lender for loaning to an applicant who can't show proof that he/she can pay the loan back or by the applicant for getting into an agreement in which they have no business being.
Believe it or not, I'm not a completely cold hearted son of a you-know-what. All of us have made mistakes from which we had to recover and, hopefully, learn a lesson. Now, three things. First, it always seemed to me to be dangerous to get into an adjustable rate mortgage in which you could only afford the teaser rate to begin with. On top of that, when you factor in that non-teaser rates were at historic lows to begin with, it seems like downright stupidity and recklessness. Ditto for the lenders that came up with these exotic loans. Also ditto for the government, which put major pressure on financial institutions to loan people money, regardless of their ability to pay. This is a
major problem I've had with the Bush administration and both parties in Congress. Less than a decade after the tech stock bubble burst, the government basically blew up the real estate bubble itself until it popped.
Secondly, what is so bad about renting a house if you can't afford to buy yet? There's no shame in that. Why would the government force banks to get people into home ownership when there is no solid evidence they can afford it? This is why I hate when the government tries to run businesses. We have 535 people, most of them lawyers with little understanding of economics, in Washington trying to run every major industry in this country.
Now, having worked for a financial institution for 4 years, I've observed that it's much easier to open an account and save than it is to qualify someone for a loan. Now, think real quick about Social Security. It should be easy to run. You collect the taxes, put the money in a separate trust fund, and disperse it back when the contributors retire. That proved way too difficult for 535 politicians, who promptly spent all the money left over after benefits were paid out. Every year. In essence, they couldn't figure out how to put money in a savings account and leave it alone. Then, these same 535 individuals decided they knew how to underwrite loan applicants better than banks, then blamed the "predatory lenders" when it all went bad. I'm not saying lenders don't deserve some share of the blame, but come on! The final outcome is thousands of homeowners unable to pay for loans which they didn't read or understand, some banks like Wachovia laying off thousands of employees, others like IndyMac going under completely, and a new bill to soak you and me for some $300 billion.
Finally, I say this as a word of warning. Markets, all markets, go up and down. It's a natural ebb and flow. We as Americans have become very spoiled and expect stocks, real estate, or whatever to rise continuously to the moon. This is setting our economy up for a very steep fall eventually. Markets
will correct themselves eventually. Nothing we can do to stop it. It's just a question of whether it will be several small, manageable corrections or one huge, Triple Crown, grand slam of a correction. Bailouts like this housing bill, the "stimulus package", etc. simply put a band-aid on a heart attack about to happen.